June 11, 2019
‘Shield’ of sea creature inspires materials that can handle their own impact without falling apart
WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. — The mantis shrimp, one of the ocean’s most ornery creatures, can take on attacks from its own species without getting injured. Its strategy could solve a big manufacturing problem: Creating lighter materials that absorb a lot of energy from a sharp impact within a limited amount of space.
Think precious cargo. What if there were a material that could prevent car ceilings from caving in on passengers during an accident, or fragile objects from breaking when transported over long distances?
The mantis shrimp’s secret is its tail appendage, called a telson. Engineers have now discovered what allows the telson to absorb the blows of its feisty self, with the goal of applying these lessons to protective gear
The work, published in the journal Advanced Functional Materials, was performed by a team of researchers including David Kisailus’ lab at the University of California, Riverside and Pablo Zavattieri’s lab at Purdue University.
A telson can be shaped either as a territorial shield for “smasher” species or as a burrowing shovel for “spearer” species that also stabs prey. The researchers found out how the telson of the smasher, compared to that of the spearer, is better at protecting the mantis.
Their findings reveal that the smasher telson has curved ridges called carinae on the outside and a helicoidal structure shaped like a spiral staircase on the inside. UC Riverside ran tests on both the mantis shrimp itself and 3D-printed replicas of the telson, showing that the carinae both stiffen a smasher’s shield and allow it to flex inward.
Together with the helicoidal structure, which prevents cracks from growing upon impact, the shield absorbs significant amounts of energy during a strike without falling apart.
Purdue researchers validated the role of carinae through computational models, simulating the attacks of one mantis against the telson of another. They even “invented” species with features between the smasher and spearer to evaluate which telson offered the best protection for the animal.
“We started with the telson of the spearer and gradually added features that start looking like the smasher,” said Zavattieri, a professor of civil engineering at Purdue. A YouTube video is available at https://youtu.be/bXEfWqXyvfA.
Researchers have shown that compared to other mantis shrimp species, the shield-like tail segment (telson) of the “smasher” species offers the best protection for the animal’s body. (Purdue University video/Pablo Zavattieri)
Download image
“The smasher shield is clearly more ideal for preventing impact from reaching the rest of the body, which makes sense because the mantis has organs all the way to its tail,” he said.
Zavattieri and Kisailus, a professor of chemical and environmental engineering and the Winston Chung Endowed Chair of Energy Innovation at UC Riverside, had previously observed the same helicoidal structure in the dactyl club appendage of the smasher mantis, which strikes a telson with the speed of a .22 caliber bullet.
“We realized that if these organisms were striking each other with such incredible forces, the telson must be architected in such a way to act like the perfect shield,” Kisailus said. “Not only did the telson of the smasher contain the helicoid microstructure, but there were significantly more energy-absorbing helicoidal layers in the smashing type than the spearing type.”
Zavattieri’s group has already begun incorporating the crack propagation mechanisms of arthropod exoskeletons into 3D-printed cement paste, a key ingredient of the concrete and mortar used to build various elements of infrastructure. His lab plans to also try out advantageous structures from the mantis shrimp.
But there are still more clues to uncover about all that carinae and helicoidal structures have to offer, the researchers say, as well as how to manufacture them into new materials.
“The dactyl club is bulky, while the telson is very lightweight. How do we make protective layers, thin films and coatings for example, that are both stronger and lighter?” Zavattieri said.
The work was financially supported by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research.
Writer: Kayla Wiles, 765-494-2432, wiles5@purdue.edu
Source: Pablo Zavattieri, 765-496-9644, zavattie@purdue.edu
Note to Journalists: For a copy of the paper, please contact Kayla Wiles, Purdue News Service, at wiles5@purdue.edu. A YouTube video is available at https://youtu.be/bXEfWqXyvfA and other multimedia can be found in a Google Drive folder at http://bit.ly/mantis-shrimp-media. The materials were prepared by Erin Easterling, digital producer for the Purdue College of Engineering, 765-496-3388, easterling@purdue.edu
ABSTRACT
The Stomatopod Telson: Convergent Evolution in the Development of a Biological Shield
Nicholas A. Yaraghi1, Adwait A. Trikanad2, David Restrepo2,3, Wei Huang1, Steven Herrera1, Roy L. Caldwell4, Pablo D. Zavattieri2, David Kisailus1
1University of California, Riverside, Riverside, CA, USA
2Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA
3The University of Texas at San Antonio, San Antonio, TX, USA
4University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, USA
Mantis shrimp are aggressive marine crustaceans well known for their rapid and powerful hunting strategies, deploying highly specialized raptorial appendages to strike and kill prey with tremendous force and speed. Less well-known, however, is the ability of some species of mantis shrimp to defend themselves from the repeated blows of conspecifics during ritualized fighting using a shield-like segment of abdominal armor called the telson. Here, we examine multi-scale structure-mechanical property relationships of this damage-tolerant biological composite in order to understand potential strategies that nature uses for resisting failure from repeated high-energy impacts. The telson structures of the smashing-type species, Odontodactylus scyllarus, and the less aggressive spearing-type species, Lysiosquillina maculata, are also compared in order to better understand the ecological pressures driving the formation and use of the telson as a biological shield. We identify a higher bulk compressive stiffness within the smasher telson, which is attributed to its concave macro-morphology, thicker cuticle, and higher degree of mineralization within its exocuticle. At the same time, the presence of ridges at the dorsal surface suggest a role in imparting compliance for energy absorption. Fracture analysis identifies an enhanced toughening mechanism of crack twisting within the smasher telson, attributed to its well-defined pitch-graded helicoidal fibrous micro-architecture. Such findings may prove useful for the design of lightweight graded composites materials with potential flexibility, multifunctionality as well as improved damage-tolerance.
