Water quality could change in buildings closed down during COVID-19 pandemic, engineers say

Study part of national effort to understand how extended shutdowns affect water quality in buildings

WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. — While restaurants, gyms, schools and other buildings are closed indefinitely to prevent the spread of COVID-19, water left sitting in pipes could change in quality.

It’s possible that water left sitting for long periods of time could contain excessive amounts of heavy metals and pathogens concentrated in pipes nationwide, say researchers who have begun a field study on the impact of a pandemic shutdown on buildings.

Purdue engineering professor Andrew Whelton holds up a water sample from a building faucet. The pink color indicates the presence of chlorine, a disinfectant. Whelton’s team is investigating how water quality might change in buildings during a time of limited occupancy due to the COVID-19 pandemic. (Purdue University photo/Matthew Kerkhoff) Download image

Stagnant water would not be a problem just for buildings recently closed down. Water could have been bad for months or years in old hospital buildings that cities are reopening to accommodate a potential influx of COVID-19 patients.

“We don’t design buildings to be shut down for months. This study focuses on the consequences and could help building owners make sure that their buildings are safe and operational when occupants return,” said Andrew Whelton, a Purdue associate professor of civil engineering and environmental and ecological engineering.

The researchers began their study upon receiving funding by the National Science Foundation’s Rapid Response Research (RAPID) program only three days after applying. The study involves monitoring water quality in buildings both during a period of extended vacancy and when occupants have returned.

A YouTube video describing this study is available at https://youtu.be/Myvlo7SKz2A.

This field study is part of a national effort to advise public health officials, building owners and water utilities on how to safely recommission buildings with low or no occupancy due to the pandemic.

Whelton and other researchers across the U.S. have begun drafting recommendations compiled by this effort in a paper pending publication. Collaborating with Purdue in this effort are experts from leading plumbing safety scientists and engineers from Virginia Tech, Legionella Risk Management Inc., Arizona State University, the University of Memphis, the University of Iowa, Northeastern University, and Polytechnique Montréal in Canada.

The recommendations are based on implications from other studies of water stagnation in large buildings. Whelton’s team also worked with the American Water Works Association to publish a set of building recommission guidelines and provided guidance to a pandemic response in Detroit as the city worked to restore water service to thousands of households that had been shut off due to inability to pay.

But since no study has been conducted on widespread, long-term building closures, knowledge gaps remain on how to best maintain stable water quality during a shutdown. The field study led by Whelton’s team would be a start to filling these gaps.

“We’re not going to have all the science done at the end of this study. But part of what we’re trying to do is put energy toward helping others develop guidelines so that they can at least go in and start recovering their buildings,” Whelton said.

Whelton’s team has previously conducted studies on school buildings shut down for the summer and large office buildings, finding that water quality changes over time. In 2019, his team was called into California after the Camp Fire and advised health officials and the community on returning their buildings to safe use. Published papers on these studies are forthcoming.

Typically, buildings can prevent stagnation through regular water use. This brings in new water with disinfectant. But extended building shutdowns will require different solutions, the researchers said.

“With normal building use throughout a district, even small amounts of water use would help draw disinfectant residual into a building. In the COVID-19 era, many low-use buildings in one area could affect the disinfectant residual in the water mains,” said Caitlin Proctor, a Lillian Gilbreth Postdoctoral Fellow at Purdue.

“As we come back to work after social distancing, even complete building flushing might not be successful in drawing in fresh water.”

For this field study, Whelton’s team is collecting samples at sinks and water fountains in three buildings – tracking temperature, oxygen, heavy metals such as lead and copper, and how microbial communities in pipes change over time.

“When you use water, you’re bringing in chlorine, nitrogen, phosphorus and a small amount of carbon. Bacteria sitting on the walls of pipes store up those nutrients for later use. But with months-long stagnation, there isn’t going to be any oxygen, new nitrogen or phosphorus,” Proctor said.

“So the bacteria that can compete under normal delivery of nutrients might not be able to compete anymore. For example, bacteria that do really well when there’s no oxygen might outcompete those that need oxygen.”

The team also is tracking a pathogen called Legionella pnuemophila, which is known to cause a bacterial form of pneumonia. Some hospital buildings already have plans in place to flush out stagnant water that could carry this pathogen, but more studies on stagnant water could inform how frequently and how long they should flush.

“It’s also important to note that not all bacterial growth is pathogenic. That’s why we’re going to look at not only the numbers of bacteria, but also the types of bacteria that are showing up,” Proctor said.

In addition to observing water left sitting still in buildings, the team will study how stagnation affects water softeners and water heaters. In the lab, the researchers will let the water sit still for long periods of time, watching for chemical and microbiological changes.

“There isn’t really any evidence on what prolonged stagnation does to these devices,” Whelton said.

The researchers are bringing together a network of organizations to be ready to act upon the study’s findings when they are available. The American Society of Plumbing Engineers and the International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials are collaborating with Whelton’s team on this study.

The study also has received input from the National Environmental Health Association and guidance from the Association of State Drinking Water Administration and Association of State and Territorial Health Officials. The findings are intended to help guide efforts by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and state and local government agencies.

Additional guidance on building plumbing during the COVID-19 pandemic are available via Purdue’s Center for Plumbing Safety.

About Purdue University

Purdue University is a top public research institution developing practical solutions to today’s toughest challenges. Ranked the No. 6 Most Innovative University in the United States by U.S. News & World Report, Purdue delivers world-changing research and out-of-this-world discovery. Committed to hands-on and online, real-world learning, Purdue offers a transformative education to all. Committed to affordability and accessibility, Purdue has frozen tuition and most fees at 2012-13 levels, enabling more students than ever to graduate debt-free. See how Purdue never stops in the persistent pursuit of the next giant leap at purdue.edu.

Writer: Kayla Wiles, wiles5@purdue.edu. Working remotely but will provide immediate response.

Sources: Available by phone and video conferencing platforms

Andrew Whelton, awhelton@purdue.edu

Caitlin Proctor, proctoc@purdue.edu

Note to Journalists: B-roll and photos of researchers collecting and analyzing water samples are available in a Google Drive folder at https://purdue.university/3c5Jfgg. A YouTube video describing the field study on water quality in buildings is available at https://youtu.be/Myvlo7SKz2A. A preprint on considerations for large building water quality after extended stagnation is available online.